Which of the following overall arguments did Hamilton make about the Articles of Confederation?

16.The failure of the Articles of Confederation resulted in which of the following changes in thegovernment of the United States?The immediate end to property qualifications for White male suffrageThe ratification of a constitution that established a stronger central governmentThe ban on women’s political participation under the ideas of republican motherhood

The enactment of the Northwest Ordinance, which outlined the admission process for new states“The United States [under the Articles of Confederation] has an indefinite discretion to make [requests]for men and money; but they have no authority to raise either, by regulations extending to theindividual citizens of America. The consequence of this is, that though in theory their resolutionsconcerning those objects are laws, constitutionally binding on the members of the Union, yet inpractice they are mere recommendations which the States observe or disregard at their option.“There is nothing absurd or impracticable in the idea of a league or alliance between independentnations for certain defined purposes . . . depending for its execution on the good faith of the parties. Intheearly part of the present century there was an [enthusiasm] in Europe for [leagues or alliances]. Theywere scarcely formed before they were broken, giving an instructive but afflicting lesson to mankind, howlittle dependence is to be placed on treaties which have no other sanction than the obligations of goodfaith. . . .“There was a time when we were told that breaches, by the States, of the regulations of the[Confederation’s] authority were not be expected. . . .“In our case, the [agreement] of thirteen distinct sovereign wills is requisite, under the Confederation, tothe complete execution of every important measure that proceeds from the Union.The measures ofthe Union have not been executed.Each State, yielding to the persuasive voice of immediate interestor convenience, has successively withdrawn its support.”Alexander Hamilton, The Federalist paper number 15, published in 1787

The name Federalists was adopted both by the supporters of ratification of the U.S. Constitution and by members of one of the nation’s first two political parties. Alexander Hamilton was an influential Federalist who wrote many of the essays in The Federalist, published in 1788. These articles advocated the ratification of the Constitution. Later, those who supported Hamilton’s aggressive fiscal policies formed the Federalist Party, which grew to support a strong national government, an expansive interpretation of congressional powers under the Constitution through the elastic clause, and a more mercantile economy. (Image via Wikimedia Commons, painted by John Trumbull circa 1805, public domain)

The name Federalists was adopted both by the supporters of ratification of the U.S. Constitution and by members of one of the nation’s first two political parties.

Federalists battled for adoption of the Constitution

In the clash in 1788 over ratification of the Constitution by nine or more state conventions, Federalist supporters battled for a strong union and the adoption of the Constitution, and Anti-Federalists fought against the creation of a stronger national government and sought to leave the Articles of Confederation, the predecessor of the Constitution, intact.

The Federalists included big property owners in the North, conservative small farmers and businessmen, wealthy merchants, clergymen, judges, lawyers, and professionals. They favored weaker state governments, a strong centralized government, the indirect election of government officials, longer term limits for officeholders, and representative, rather than direct, democracy.

Federalists published the Federalist papers in New York City newspapers

Faced with forceful Anti-Federalist opposition to a strong national government, the Federalists published a series of 85 articles in New York City newspapers in which they advocated ratification of the Constitution. A compilation of these articles written by James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay (under the pseudonym Publius), were published as The Federalist in 1788.

Through these papers and other writings, the Federalists successfully articulated their position in favor of adoption of the Constitution.

James Madison was another author of the Federalist Papers. To ensure adoption of the Constitution, the Federalists, such as James Madison, promised to add amendments specifically protecting individual liberties. These amendments, including the First Amendment, became the Bill of Rights. James Madison later became a Democratic-Republican and opposed many Federalist policies.
(Image via the White House Historical Association, painted by John Vanderlyn in 1816, public domain)

Federalists argued for counterbalancing branches of government

In light of charges that the Constitution created a strong national government, they were able to argue that the separation of powers among the three branches of government protected the rights of the people. Because the three branches were equal, none could assume control over the other.

When challenged over the lack of individual liberties, the Federalists argued that the Constitution did not include a bill of rights because the new Constitution did not vest in the new government the authority to suppress individual liberties.

The Federalists further argued that because it would be impossible to list all the rights afforded to Americans, it would be best to list none.

In the end, however, to ensure adoption of the Constitution, the Federalists promised to add amendments specifically protecting individual liberties (Federalists such as James Madison ultimately agreed to support a bill of rights largely to head off the possibility of a second convention that might undo the work of the first).

Federalists compromised and adopted the Bill of Rights

Thus upon ratification of the Constitution, Madison introduced 12 amendments during the First Congress in 1789. States ratified 10 of these amendments, now designated as the Bill of Rights, in 1791. The first of these amendments contains guarantees of freedom of religion, speech, press, peaceable assembly, and petition and has also been interpreted to protect the right of association.

In 1798, during the administration of John Adams, the Federalists attempted to squelch dissent by adopting the Sedition Act, which restricted freedom of speech and the press. Although the Federalist Party was strong in New England and the Northeast, it was left without a strong leader after the death of Alexander Hamilton and retirement of Adams. Its increasingly aristocratic tendencies and its opposition to the War of 1812 helped to fuel its demise in 1816.
(Image via the U.S. Navy, painted by Asher Brown Durand between 1735 and 1826, public domain)

Federalist Party emerged to support Alexander Hamilton's policies

Although the Bill of Rights enabled Federalists and Anti-Federalists to reach a compromise that led to the adoption of the Constitution, this harmony did not extend into the presidency of George Washington; political divisions within the cabinet of the newly created government emerged in 1792 over national fiscal policy, splitting those who previously supported the Constitution into rival groups, some of whom allied with former Anti-Federalists.

Those who supported Alexander Hamilton’s aggressive fiscal policies formed the Federalist Party, which later grew to support a strong national government, an expansive interpretation of congressional powers under the Constitution through the elastic clause, and a more mercantile economy.

Their Democratic-Republican opponents, led by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, tended to emphasize states’ rights and agrarianism. In 1798, during the administration of John Adams, the Federalists attempted to squelch dissent by adopting the Sedition Act, which restricted freedom of speech and the press, but opposition to this law helped Democratic-Republicans gain victory in the elections of 1800.

Federalist Party ended in 1816

Although the Federalist Party was strong in New England and the Northeast, it was left without a strong leader after the death of Alexander Hamilton and retirement of John Adams. Its increasingly aristocratic tendencies and its opposition to the War of 1812 helped to fuel its demise in 1816.

This article was originally published in 2009. Mitzi Ramos is an Instructor of Political Science at Northeastern Illinois University.

Send Feedback on this article

Which of the following was a piece of evidence Hamilton used to support his argument in this excerpt?

Which of the following does the author use to support his argument about the power of the states under the confederation?

Which of the following best explains a result of the Seven Years War quizlet?

Which of the following ways best explains how the United States attempted to influence?